Another
cogent name for this book would be triumph of the human ingenuity. A
perspective changer, written by Edward Glaeser. As its name suggests it,
emphasizes on how cities came into existence and how they serve society. It
would sure be an eye opener for urban environmentalists, activists (like me)
who indulge in romanticizing country side, villages, greens. India has a
tradition of idealizing small independent village societies. This book very
aptly explains why this view is wrong in current scenario. Surely, this book is
not incisive just because it weaves its ideas around economic buzz words
(concepts) viz. efficiency and productivity (which are as abstract and
subjective as concept of infinity), but it is based on a strong logical plinth.
It summarizes
widely analyzed views about benefits of agglomerations. How cities are in
tandem with current dominating economic frameworks. If you try to fathom the
thought, you will realize its decisiveness. With growing population and
extensive strain on resources there is no solution other than cities, big dense
metropolitan areas. While Glaeser explains dislocated ideas in environmental
activism. I could remember Humfry from Yes Minister, who implies environment is
for urban youth. In a nut shell carbon foot prints generate by a city are much
less as compared tosmall bungalow surrounded by laurels.Costs are restoring
heritage monuments are much higher than satisfaction. Obviously some monuments
ought to be restored but obsession with it is futile.
It portrays
slums as an efficient housing. In cities like Mumbai where property prices are exorbitant,
this housing provides a way out for lower income people in city. This is true
at lest in case of Mumbai and must be in case of other cities. Slums are
solutions and not problems.
A must read
book though written lucidly, explains ideas in a sharp manner.